Class 7 · Unit project
Unit 5 project: The fair-AI check-up
The school is thinking about using an AI system. Before anyone switches it on, your group gives it a check-up: who could it fail, who must stay in charge, and what must people be told?
The task
This unit you caught a biased leaf detector, named three kinds of bias, ran a decision desk, rewrote a consent form and signed a class charter. Today the school is thinking about an AI system — and nobody switches it on until your group has given it a check-up.
Work in groups of 3–4. One period. Everything in checkup-<group>.odt.
Your system (from your teacher's pack)
Each group gets one card — every system and every number invented for teaching:
- The talking library: a voice assistant that finds books when you ask. Its test table: understood 93 of 100 requests in the teacher's voice, 58 of 100 from Class 6 pupils.
- The homework checker: marks English homework automatically. Trained on essays from big-city schools; its test table shows it marks local place names as "spelling mistakes".
- The late-comer camera: counts who arrives after 9:00. Tested in summer; its winter test shows it misses a third of arrivals in fog and snow.
- The club picker: suggests which pupils join the science club, trained on ten years of club lists in which girls rarely appeared.
Check it (25 min)
- Predict: is this system fair enough to use? Write yes, no or yes-if at the top.
- Find the bias. Which group does it fail? Which kind — missing-group, historical, measurement? Quote the number from the card that shows it. What's the fix?
- Human in the loop. List what it decides. Mark each low or high stakes. For each high-stakes one: who checks it, and what might they know that the system doesn't?
- The notice. Write the notice people would get, answering the six questions — what, why, who, how long, how to say no, and is an AI used, and what does it do? Under 100 words, and no personal data collected that it doesn't need.
- Your verdict: yes, no or yes-if — with your conditions. Did it match your prediction?
Your own line (5 min, alone)
Each person writes one promise for the class charter — "We will…" — that this system taught you. Sign with your roll number. This part is marked for you alone.
Share (5 min)
Each group reads its bias number and its verdict.
How it is marked
Each row is marked 0–3. Rows 1–5 are shared by the group; row 6 is yours alone. Marks are returned privately and never compared with anyone else's.
Total: 18. A group that says no with good reasons can score full marks.
1. The bias
- 0Missing
- 1"It's unfair"
- 2Group and kind named
- 3Group, kind and the number that proves it
2. The fix
- 0Missing
- 1"Fix the AI"
- 2A fix
- 3A fix that matches that kind of bias
3. Human in the loop
- 0Missing
- 1"A person checks"
- 2High-stakes decisions named, with who checks
- 3And what that person knows that the system doesn't
4. The notice
- 0Missing
- 1Some questions
- 2All six answered
- 3All six, plainly, and nothing extra collected
5. The verdict
- 0Missing
- 1No reasons
- 2Verdict with reasons
- 3Yes-if with checkable conditions, or a reasoned no
6. A charter promise
Just you- 0Missing
- 1"Don't…"
- 2A "We will…" promise
- 3A promise someone could check was kept